We Put More Money Back in Your Pocket by Streamlining Medicare & Marketplace Health Insurance.
We Help Clients Nationwide Save Money on:
- Dental & Vision - Prescription Drug Plans - Final Expense Life Insurance - Food Benefit Card - Medicare Advantage - Medicare Supplement - Hospital & Rx Cash Back Programs - Heart Attack, Cancer, Stroke Payouts - Annuities & Retirement Planning - Debt Relief -
- Dental & Vision - Prescription Drug Plans - Final Expense Life Insurance - Food Benefit Card - Medicare Advantage - Medicare Supplement - Hospital & Rx Cash Back Programs - Heart Attack, Cancer, Stroke Payouts - Annuities & Retirement Planning - Debt Relief -
Featured Products & Services
Medicare, SSA & Medicaid Guidance
Getting your Medicare card through SSA.gov can be frustrating, and choosing the right Medicare plan is one of the biggest financial decisions you'll make in retirement. Get personalized Medicare guidance, walk you through the SSA website click by click, and help you find state programs that could lower your costs.
Estate & Retirement Planning
Retire with confidence using strategies that maximize your income while avoiding market volatility. Through retirement income planning, trusts, living wills, and advance directives, we help secure your financial future and bring you peace of mind.
Final Expense Insurance
With a brokerage portfolio of 80+ carriers, we’ll make sure you have the final expense life insurance that protects your loved ones and saves you money. From funeral costs to legacy planning, we ensure your family is covered with affordable, reliable solutions.
ACA Marketplace Health Insurance
Navigating the ACA health insurance marketplace in Montana & other states can be confusing. That’s why we’re here to simplify the process and compare top-rated plans. Whether you need individual, family, or small business owner coverage, we’ll help you qualify for your maximum subsidy on health care.
Prescription & Cashback Program
The Hospital & Prescription Cash Back Program by Old Western Insurance offers up to $60/month reimbursement for prescription costs, even if your copay is $0. Additionally, it provides cash benefits for hospital stays, in-home care, and ambulance services, with direct deposits typically within 3 days.
- Dental & Vision - Prescription Drug Plans - Final Expense Life Insurance - Food Benefit Card - Medicare Advantage - Medicare Supplement - Hospital & Rx Cash Back Programs - Heart Attack, Cancer, Stroke Payouts - Annuities & Retirement Planning - Debt Relief -
- Dental & Vision - Prescription Drug Plans - Final Expense Life Insurance - Food Benefit Card - Medicare Advantage - Medicare Supplement - Hospital & Rx Cash Back Programs - Heart Attack, Cancer, Stroke Payouts - Annuities & Retirement Planning - Debt Relief -
Why I Started Old Western Insurance
Hi, I’m Clay Murdock! I started Old Western Insurance because I realized farmers, ranchers, rural Americans — really, all Americans — needed better options and better guidance when it came to protecting their health, their families, and what they’ve worked for.
Before I was a licensed agent, I was unexpectedly diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes. Up until that moment, I had always thought I didn’t really need health insurance. Suddenly, I was looking at the cost of insulin and wondering how my family and I were going to afford keeping me healthy until I could enroll in coverage at the end of the year.
I was afraid medical costs could put everything my family had worked for at risk — including our family ranch. That fear was especially real because my family had already been through something similar when my aunt, who was also diabetic, was a baby and no insurance company would accept her. I found out pretty quickly how scary it was trying to figure everything out on my own. I didn’t know who to call, I didn’t know who to trust, and I doubted anyone would take my health needs as seriously as I would.
What I did know was that without the right coverage, I couldn’t live the healthy and safe life I needed to live. So I figured it out. I became an insurance broker and started Old Western Insurance so I could give other people the kind of help I wished I’d had.
Old Western Insurance was built to help real people protect their families, farms, ranches, businesses, and finances from both the expected and unexpected costs of healthcare.
When you work with me on Medicare or Marketplace health insurance, my strategy isn’t just to pick a plan and leave you with it. I give you a comprehensive review of your healthcare situation and can recommend additional coverage that may help fill the gaps, save you money, or even get you checks in the mail. I often recommend stacking on coverage for dental, vision, hospital stays, cancer, heart attack, stroke, and other major healthcare expenses.
And my work goes beyond health insurance. As someone who grew up on a farm and ranch, I believe farmers and ranchers are already stretched too thin in most cases, and too often the wrong people are getting wealthy in our industry. That’s also why I help families with financial and retirement strategies that can protect them from catastrophe, improve cash flow, and help them hold on to more of what they’ve built.
As a current MBA candidate, I’m using Old Western Insurance and my degree program to work toward making rural communities stronger. When you work with Old Western Insurance, you’re supporting agriculture and rural families nationwide.
2027 Enrollment & Review Scheduling
Enrollment Dates
Existing Clients
Your reserved review dates
New Clients
General enrollment dates
Existing Old Western Insurance clients: Clay takes hundreds of calls during this time of year. These review dates are set aside especially for you, so you don’t get lost in the shuffle.
New clients: Feel free to grab any available time that works for you during the general enrollment dates.
Choose Your Appointment
Why Clients Choose Old Western Insurance
We Do Old Western Values: Honesty, Hard Work, and Hospitality
If you’re here, you’re our neighbor!
“Our mission is to help seniors secure their future with simple, personalized, and effective insurance and financial solutions.
At Old Western Insurance, we blend modern expertise with timeless values—honesty, hard work, and a no-nonsense approach—so you can focus on what matters most: your family.
Our job is to ensure you get everything you’re entitled to and don’t miss out on opportunities because you didn’t know.
And our promise? A friendly, transparent conversation that leaves you in a better place than where you started.
These are Old Western Values—timeless and welcoming.”
-Clay S. Murdock
How We Do Business
Personalized Guidance
We understand that everyone’s journey is unique. That’s why we take the time to listen, understand your goals, and provide solutions tailored to you. Whether you’re working with our life insurance agents in Billings, MT, or exploring Medicare options, our focus is always on your security and satisfaction.
Modern Solutions
Our innovative approach combines cutting-edge tools with timeless values, giving you the confidence that every decision is supported by both modern technology and proven principles. We focus on delivering the most effective and efficient solutions tailored to your Medicare needs, final expense life insurance, and retirement planning, so you and your loved ones can enjoy peace of mind today and security for the future.
Competitive Name Brands
We partner with names in the industry that you recognize, we offer reliable state regulated and affordable plans that prioritize your security and satisfaction.We partner with trusted names in the industry to provide affordable, state-regulated plans that put your well-being first. From the health insurance Montana marketplace to the best health insurance in Billings, Montana, our goal is to give you confidence in every choice.